Monday, 9 June 2014

Using Pin Bar Trading Strategy in Momentum Trading

 this article you will learn the various aspects of the Pin Bar Trading Strategy used during a Pin Bar momentum break. Some of these features include the conditions needed for a potential long or short entry consisting of a single price bar/candle and the optimum time to place a stop loss.
A breakdown of the results of back testing for EUR/USD, GBP/USD and USD/JPY during three different time frames--daily, 4 hour, and 1 hour--is also discussed in detail.
This is the 2nd article in the Momentum Trading Strategy series. The first one can be found here: Outside Bar Momentum Strategy.

STRATEGY #2 – PIN BAR MOMENTUM BREAK

Entry

A potential entry when using the Pin Bar Trading Strategy is identified from one single price bar/candle. The candle just needs to meet two conditions when it closes:
1. It must be a Pin Bar – this is a bar with an open and close that are both in either the top quarter of its range, or the bottom quarter of its range.
2. If the Pin Bar closes in the upper quarter of its range, its low must be lower than the low of the previous 4 candles. If the Pin Bar closes in the lower quarter of its range, its high must be higher than the high of the previous 4 candles.
If the bar closes in the upper quarter of its range, if we are using the Pin Bar Trading Strategy we are looking for its high to be exceeded by at least one pip by the very next bar, and at this price we enter long. However if the price trades below the low of the Pin Bar before this happens, the entry is not taken.
If the bar closes in the lower quarter of its range, we are looking for its low to be exceeded by at least one pip by the very next bar, and at this price we enter short. However if the price trades above the high of the Pin Bar before this happens, the entry is not taken.
Examples of entries and stop loss placements in Pin Bar trading are shown below:

Long Entry:

long entry pin bar trading
Note that both the open and the close are in the top quarter of the candle. The candle’s low is lower than the lows of all of the previous 4 candles.
The long entry order is shown by the dotted green line, 1 pip above the high of the candle that has just closed.
The stop loss is shown by the dotted red line, 1 pip below the low of the candle that has just closed.
The order must now be triggered by the next candle, before the red line is hit.

Short Entry:

Short entry pin bar trading
Note that both the open and the close are in the bottom quarter of the candle. The candle’s high is higher than the highs of all of the previous 4 candles.
The short entry order is shown by the dotted green line, 1 pip below the low of the candle that has just closed.
The stop loss is shown by the dotted red line, 1 pip above the high of the candle that has just closed.
The order must now be triggered by the next candle, before the red line is hit.

Stop Loss

The stop loss is simply placed one pip beyond the other side of the candle. If the trade is long, it is placed one pip below the low of the candle. If the trade is short, it is placed one pip above the high of the candle.
Regarding Profit Targets and Issues, the information given on Page 7 for Strategy #1 is also applicable here.

Pin Bar Trading Strategy Justification

A Pin Bar may indicate the sudden rejection, with momentum, of a particular price level or zone. It is therefore indicative of momentum and impulsiveness and possibly identifies that an S/R level or zone has been reached from which the price has been rejected.
The open close of the Outside Bar in either the top or bottom quartile, and the breaking of that quartile during the next bar before the other side is broken, are further indications of strong momentum in the direction of the trade.

STRATEGY #2 – PIN BAR MOMENTUM BREAK: BACK TEST RESULTS:

The testing was conducted on only the 1 hour and 4 hour time frames. The historical data used ran from 1st November 2003 to 30th October 2013.
London time was used and is given in the results. During half of the year, London time and GMT differ by 1 hour.

Daily Time Frame

Signals were few and on this time frame are better considered strongly on their individual merits. For these reasons, no results are given here.

H4 Time Frame

The historical data used ran from 1st November 2003 to 31st October 2013.
The hypothetical results were as follows:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table01
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table02
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table03
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table04
The hypothetical results seem to be disappointing. We have a fairly large sample of 661 trades overall and the winning percentage is just a shade above random.
Applying the “larger than the previous 5 candles” filter makes a significant difference to the hypothetical results of both the GBP/USD and USD/JPY pairs:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table05
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table06
Although the sample sizes are small, the winning ratios are very high in the case of GBP/USD and nicely high in the case of USD/JPY. This is a rare trade, but historically has performed well over the past decade.
I find these results plausible as the filter helps to identify relative impulsiveness of new moves which tend to be reversals. The fact that the filter has the greatest impact on GBP/USD and the least impact on EUR/USD can be explained by the relative liquidities of the pairs, with the EUR/USD being prone to ranging behavior and the GBP/USD being prone to momentum behavior.
Applying the time of day filter is useful in highlighting a historically useful time in the USD/JPY pair only. Of the candles closing at 8am GMT, 63.16% produced hypothetical winning trades over the past decade, out of a total of 38 trades. I find this result plausible as it coincides with the final part of the Tokyo session and the opening of the London session which can provide the impetus for a move.
Taking all the highlighted trades on the H4 timeframe in total, this would have produced a positive hypothetical expectancy of 28.40% per trade.
An average of about 8 trades was triggered per year, about 0.67 per month.
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table07

H1 Time Frame

The historical data used ran from 1st November 2003 to 31st October 2013.
The hypothetical results were as follows:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table08
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table09
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table10
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table11
The hypothetical results seem to be disappointing. We have a very large sample of 3118 trades overall and the winning percentage is effectively random.
Let’s take each pair and see if their respective hypothetical results can be improved by filters:

EUR/USD

After applying the time of day filter, the only hypothetical result worth highlighting came from the 56 trades that were triggered between 2am and 3am London time, coinciding with the Tokyo open. 58.93% of these trades were winners. I do not see this as a meaningful result as there is nothing significant happening at this time.
By applying the “larger than previous 5 candles” filter over all the trades regardless of time of day, it was possible to secure a significant hypothetical result:

The significant gap between the long and short trades is concerning, so this should be refined further. The results for the London session as a whole bring the winning percentage to just a few points over the 55% cut off, but it is the results for the time period covering the London / New York session overlap (between 1pm and 5pm London time, typically the time of greatest market liquidity) that are really impressive and roughly equal between long and short trades.

This is a plausible result due to the high liquidity and volume usually present during the London / New York session overlaps.
It should also be noted that with a much larger sample size, all the trades taken during the London session excluding its first hour (i.e. from 9am to 5pm London time) produced the following hypothetical result with an almost identical winning percentage:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table14
This could be a plausible result. However, as can be seen, the gap between long and short trades is huge, so I do not find it reliable.
The London / New York overlap trade looks the most solid here.

GBP/USD

After applying the time of day filter, the only hypothetical result worth highlighting came from the 75 trades that were triggered between 8am and 9am London time, coinciding with the London open. 62.67% of these trades were winners. This is a significant result as it coincides with the beginning of the most important session in which this pair is traded.
By applying the “larger than previous 5 candles” filter over all the trades regardless of time of day, it was possible to secure a significant hypothetical result:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table15
The hypothetical result above can be filtered effectively and logically by restricting entry times to between 8am and 5pm London time, improving the winning rates of both long and short trades as shown in the hypothetical results below:

These are significant results as the filters identify momentum and impulsiveness and restrict trades to the predominant London session.

USD/JPY

Applying the time of day filter, at least on its own, made no difference.
By applying the “larger than previous 5 candles” filter over all the trades regardless of time of day, it was possible to secure a significant hypothetical result:
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table17
This is not good enough to be of interest. However, combining this filter with trading only between 3pm and 5pm London time during part of the London / New York session overlap produced an excellent win rate, but a very small sample size:

Taking all the highlighted trades on the H1 timeframe in total, this would have produced a positive hypothetical expectancy of 30.56% per trade.
An average of about 22 trades was triggered per year, just under 1.9 per month.
Outside-Bar-Trading-Strategy-table19
I do not consider this to be a significant result as there is nothing significant about these particular two hours of the London session, despite their being part of the London / New York sessions overlap.
TIME MAP OF HISTORICALLY PROFITABLE TRADES USING STRATEGIES #1 / #2*
TIME MAP OF HISTORICALLY PROFITABLE TRADES
* Strategy #1 refers to the first article in the Momentum Trading Strategies seriese that tests the Outside Bar Trading Strategy. Click here to read it.
Overall, the results show that volatility and time of day are important factors in determining market movement predictability after candlestick patterns.

Is it Time to Quit Indicators and Turn to Forex Price Action?

If a survey was handed out to retail Forex and Futures traders and one of the questions that was asked was “what method or system did they first trade with”, without a doubt the huge majority of traders would say they started with indicators such as moving averages, stochastic, MACD, Bollinger Bands and the list of goes on and on.
I am super lucky that I get to talk and help traders with their trading goals every day, and the list of systems and methods that I come across with indicators is endless. You only have to look in any Forex forum to see how many new traders are clambering all over the “Forex Systems” threads looking for the latest indicators and EA’s because people come up with new indicator systems every chance they get (not necessarily a profitable ones).
The reason indicators are so popular is that they feed into the new trader’s belief that the indicator can help predict where price is going to go. To understand indicators properly traders need to understand how indicators are built and project their information. 99% of all indicators are built using old price information to make a lagging indicator. For example; a moving average is built using old price to make a moving line that traders can use in a number of ways.
The major problem with indicators is that they are always lagging and traders are using previous information to guide them. In other words; they are using lagging information to make live trading calls.

A Dangerous Trading Mindset

The other major worry with indicators is that traders very rarely stop at one indicator and this is often where things begin to go pair shaped in the trader’s mindset. A new trader will often have one or two winners with their first indicator. It does not matter how many losses the trader has or even if they blow their whole account. What the trader will tend to remember is that first indicator helped them make a winning trade and most of all the trader will remember that this first indicator helped them predict correctly where price was going. All the bad thoughts and losses have been completely pushed to the side because the trader has already moved onto what is coming next and they have already worked out EXACTLY how they will make it all back and much more.
The trader will often think “if one indicator helped me make a winning trade, then two indicators is sure to help me predict where price is going even better”, and then when two doesn’t help, three has to be even better etc, but the problem is that like so many things in trading it simply just doesn’t work this way as I explain below. Humans in everyday life are programmed to think that anything worthwhile cannot be simple and new traders often spend a lot of their time trying to make trading complicated adding fancy indicators to their trading thinking that the more indicators they add, the more they will be able to predict where price will go, but this is the COMPLETE opposite of what traders need to do.
This mindset is a trap that is very easy to fall into because the trader can quickly find themselves adding more and more indicators as they start having more and more losses with the incorrect mindset that indicators will help them predict where price is going. What ends up happening is the trader go’s from the start of their trading journey being in the best mindset to play trades, to having so many indicators on their charts and being in a complete mess and state of analysis paralysis. The trader ends up having so many indicators on their charts that they all end up contradicting each other and the trader can no longer make a trade because they are so confused at what they should do. So what does the trader need to do?

Time to Move to Price Action

The most simple and uncomplicated trading method in the world is price action. All that is needed for trading price action is a blank raw price action chart and your trading method. The major difference between indicators and price action is; with indicators you are using old lagging price action information to try to predict the future, but with price action you are continually reading the raw and live price as it is being printed on the chart.
There are no indicators or outside influences at all used to trade price action. Basically price action trading is the skill of being able to read the price and make trades on any chart, in any market, in any time frame and without the use of any indicators at all. Below are two charts side by side with the price action chart on the left with just raw price action and the chart full of indicators on the right hand side.
Education and commitment are needed to be successful with price action trading just like any other trading methods or systems that are worthwhile, but the reason price action trading is so successful and so many professional traders use it is because it simplifies the trading process and the mindset required to be profitable.
Safe trading and all the success,
Johnathon Fox

Don’t Ignore the Minor Pairs

any retail traders start out either restricting their trading to a few pairs, or trading every instrument they can get their hands on. Why is this?
Taking the first example, there are frequently quoted reasons for a beginner to restrict themselves to just a few major pairs, such as the EUR/USD and GBP/USD. Some of these include:
  1. These pairs are most active during European / North American hours, which might be the preferred hours of trading.
  2. Spreads are low.
  3. These pairs tend to “behave” technically, and most popular trading systems tend to be designed around their characteristics.
  4. Avoiding the confusion and stress that can come from trying to day trade many different instruments at once.
  5. Most material on the internet is based on these currency pairs.
Are these really good reasons to restrict trading to just the EUR/USD and GBP/USD? I argue that they are not, and that traders should take a more sophisticated approach:
  1. Pretty much every pair has its greatest volume and activity during European/North American hours anyway.
  2. Having to pay a higher spread for minor pairs compared to the majors should not be any obstacle to profitability, provided that trades are held for the medium or long-term.
  3. It is possible to devise perfectly good trading strategies for the pairs that tend to behave less technically.
  4. Confusion can be avoided if you know what you are looking for and manage your desk with discipline.
It is incredible that there is so much material on the internet that presents a trading system and ends with the throwaway line “works with the EUR/USD, GBP/USD, and should be OK with other pairs too”. It’s a little like a surgeon perfecting an operative procedure and grabbing a passerby to operate on!
This is not a good way to manage the transition from trading just a few pairs to looking for trades throughout the entire currency universe. It is much better to make this jump in a more controlled way, so don’t be like those traders that start with EUR/USD, get bored and start trying to trade everything the same way.
Let’s look at some numbers that will demonstrate clearly why it is definitely worth being prepared to trade minor pairs. Here is a table showing the maximum percentage fluctuation in value by currency pair over the last three calendar years, including 2013 to date. The maximum fluctuation is effectively the value of the biggest winning trade you could have made without leverage on that pairs for the year given.
Forex pairs 122513
The first thing to note from these statistics is that it is most of the major pairs (EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/CHF and USD/CAD) that have presented the most limited opportunities. See how EUR/USD, so beloved by new traders, actually offered less during 2013 than anything else, as did GBP/USD during both 2012 and 2011.
The next item of interest is that the big story of the last two years has been the Japanese yen. The best opportunities have been offered by going long against the JPY with just about anything, even the USD, but better results have been achieved with risk currencies such as the GBP and EUR. Even before the Yen was topping the Mcurrency headlines, we can see that during 2011 it was still offering better opportunities than anything except the Swiss Franc, which was in a strong uptrend during 2010 and 2011.
Finally, note how AUD/USD had more to offer every year than either EUR/USD or GBP/USD.
This should give plenty of food for thought to traders who think it is best to ignore the Yen because they are asleep during Tokyo hours, or because they don’t like the high spreads and occasionally wild action on the Yen crosses like GBP/JPY.
Of course, these numbers would not mean anything if it was really so much easier to trade pairs like EUR/USD than GBP/JPY. I contend that while it may be 50% more difficult, if there is going to be something like 300% more reward on offer, the extra risk is worth it! One solution could be to risk much less per pip on the Yen pair and crosses, and use much wider stop losses. If you can do this and catch the beginning of a really big move, there is a lot of potential on the table to take advantage of.
It is worth taking a closer look at the claim that the Yen crosses are hard to trade, in spite of their larger directional moves. While they do tend to be more volatile and “behave” less well technically, there is no reason why a trader cannot try to trade them from daily or 4 hour charts using wide stops. If these crosses are hard to day trade, why day trade them? Continue day trading with the major pairs, and try to position/swing/trend trade with the Yen crosses at the same time.
To sum up: try to think of the bigger picture. Each of the previous three years has had a “star” performing currency. It was the CHF in 2011 and the JPY in 2012 and 2013. It should help your results for 2014 if you do not exclude the next “star” from your trading, and make sure that you have some exposure to the Yen and the Australian Dollar. If you are going to stick to the majors, do include USD.
Finally, you do not have to trade the crosses in the same way as you trade the majors. You could stick to the majors and if it feels like long EUR/USD and long USD/JPY, why not just take a position right away long EUR/JPY? You don’t necessarily need to be watching the crosses technically to find the opportunities.